Awards for 1996
All-Blue Team | | All-Orange Team
Best 1st First Round Pick
Joey Galloway - WR - Warriors
Best Defensive Player
Zach Thomas - LB - Slayers Most Valuable Player
Green Bay Quarterback - Norsemen
All-Blue Team
| HC | Marv Levy | Archers Who Say Ni |
| QB | Jacksonville | Iradicators |
| RB | Emmitt Smith | Barbarians |
| RB | Ricky Watters | Archers Who Say Ni |
| WR | Herman Moore | Archers Who Say Ni |
| WR | Joey Galloway | Warriors |
| TE | Shannon Sharpe | Barbarians |
| K | Houston | Barbarians |
| OL | Denver | Warriors |
| DL | Bruce Smith | Iradicators |
| DL | Eric Swann | Iradicators |
| LB | Junior Seau | Warriors |
| LB | Ken Norton | Iradicators |
| DB | Rod Woodson | Barbarians |
| DB | Todd Lyght | Iradicators |
| HC | Bill Cowher | Norsemen |
| QB | Green Bay | Norsemen |
| RB | Terrell Davis | Norsemen |
| RB | Terry Allen | Renegades |
| WR | Tony Martin | Norsemen |
| WR | Carl Pickens | Renegades |
| TE | Ken Dilger | Slayers |
| K | San Diego | Tsunami |
| OL | Pittsburgh | Renegades |
| DL | Chris Doleman | Fighting Squirrels |
| DL | Wayne Martin | Renegades |
| LB | Zach Thomas | Slayers |
| LB | Sam Mills | Renegades |
| DB | Leroy Butler | Norsemen |
| DB | Victor Green | Slayers |